Is Tinsley Mortimer the Real-Life Lily van der Woodsen?
By Alexus Mosley
Tinsley Mortimer at the 2005 Met Gala
Photo Credit: Getty Images
When Gossip Girl introduced us to Lily van der Woodsen, she gifted us with a certain Upper East Side archetype. She was blonde, pedigreed, and effortlessly polished with a life that was 2 parts scandal, 2 parts couture.
Life has a funny way of imitating art because that sounds much Tinsley Mortimer.
Pre-reality TV and Instagram, the girls who were “famous for being famous” were women like Tinsley. Real-life Lily van der Woodsens who were born into wealth, crowned at Debutante balls, and studied at the Ivys before marrying into even more wealth.
As a descendant of two of the First Families of Virginia ( a group of early settler families from Europe who became a politically and socially dominant group in the British Colony of Virginia, later the Commonwealth of Virginia) Tinsley Mortimer was born in Richmond, Virginia, to Dale Tatum Mercer, an interior designer and socialite, and real estate investor, George Riley Mercer Jr. That quite literally makes her a descendant of Thomas Jefferson. It doesn’t get any more elite than that!
Before she made her debut into society, she attended the oldest, private all-girls school, St. Catherine’s School in Richmond, and then attended the illustrious Lawrenceville School, a boarding school in New Jersey whose notable alumni include Malcolm Forbes (publisher of Forbes magazine) and U.S. Congressman from New York, Walter G. Andrews.
Tinsley Mortimer at Frick Annual Young Fellows Ball at The Frick in 2007
Photo Credit: Getty Images
Floating through Manhattan society with glossy curls, a to die for wardrobe, and a last name that opened doors faster than Chuck Bass can down a scotch, she attended Columbia University, where she played varsity tennis while pursuing a Bachelor’s in art history and even served as a Beauty Editor at Vogue before making her own name in the fashion industry with her handbag line, "Samantha Thavasa by Tinsley Mortimer", debuting in 2006. And if these things were “Lily-coded” enough, the details of how she met her first husband, Robert Livingston, best known as Topper, will do the trick. The two met while at boarding school and eloped. Their parents forced them to annul the marriage (sounds so much like a CeCe Rhodes plot), but they managed to remarry in 2006. Their marriage ended in 2010, but in true Upper East Side fashion, she remarried businessman Robert Bovard in Palm Beach in 2023. (Hey! Not quite as many ex-husbands as Lily van der Woodsen, formerly Mueller, Bass, and Humphrey but each marriage as glamorous.)
Tinsley Mortimer during NYFW 2005
Photo Credit: Getty Images
The press adores her, Page Six tracks her, and society columns practically engraved her initials into Park Avenue marble. Much like Lily, she lives at the glamorous intersection of luxury, society, and fashion.
So… is she the real-life Lily van der Woodsen? In theory? Absolutely.
We've Finally Figured Out Why Serena van der Woodsen Always Had to Go