Is Hailey Bieber Reheating Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy's Nachos?

Is Hailey Bieber Reheating Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy's Nachos?

By Alexus Mosley

Two archival looks, one legendary fashion icon, one modern trendsetter, and a question worth asking: Where does inspiration end and imitation begin? They say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. But when it comes to fashion, is there a fine line between paying homage and reheating somebody else's nachos?

Lately, Hailey Bieber has been spending quite a bit of time in Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy's fashion archives. The model and Rhode founder has recently stepped out in not one, but two looks made famous by the late '90s style icon. And while we're certainly not opposed to a little vintage fashion appreciation, the wears have us raising an eyebrow. Or two.

First on the Menu was a Little Narciso Rodriguez. Back in September, Bieber attended an event in London wearing a champagne-colored, crystal-embellished Cerruti slip dress designed by Narciso Rodriguez for the label's Spring 1997 collection. If it sounds familiar, it’s because the dress was the very same one Bessette-Kennedy wore to her 1996 wedding rehearsal dinner before marrying John F. Kennedy Jr. And we don't just mean the same design. We're talking about the actual dress. Fashion lovers took notice. After all, few wardrobes have achieved the legendary status of CBK's, and getting one's hands on an original piece from her closet is quite the fashion accomplishment. But apparently, Hailey wasn't finished.

Photo Credit: IG/Dani Michelle

Photo Credit: Carole Radziwill

She came back for Seconds in Yohji Yamamoto when, on November 18, Bieber attended The New York Times DealBook Summit in New York City wearing a black Yohji Yamamoto jacket from the designer's Spring 1998 collection, paired with a cream-colored pencil skirt, black pumps, and a headband. The ensemble was strikingly similar to one Bessette-Kennedy wore to a Robin Hood Foundation benefit in 1998. Although Bieber's jacket wasn't Carolyn's actual garment, it was the same archival design, styled in nearly identical fashion. At this point, we couldn't help but wonder: Is Hailey building a wardrobe or conducting a very stylish tribute act?

Photo Credit: Adam Gray / Getty Images

Photo Credit: STARTRAKS PHOTO

So Inspiration or Imitation? To be fair, Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy's influence on contemporary fashion is hardly a secret. Her love of minimalist silhouettes, impeccable tailoring, and understated accessories has inspired countless women, and Bieber's own personal style has long embraced many of those same elements. There's also something to be said for bringing beautiful archival fashion back into the spotlight. After all, great clothes deserve to be worn, not simply admired in photographs.

Still, there's a difference between taking inspiration from someone's aesthetic and recreating their most recognizable outfits almost piece for piece. And when it happens twice in such a short period, the comparison becomes rather difficult to ignore. Does that make Bieber's fashion choices any less fabulous? Not necessarily, as both looks are undeniably chic. But part of what made Bessette-Kennedy's style so unforgettable was the seemingly effortless individuality she brought to every ensemble. And while anyone can revisit a great outfit, capturing the magic that made it iconic in the first place is another matter entirely.

So, is Hailey Bieber paying tribute to a fashion legend, or simply reheating Carolyn's nachos? We'll let you be the judge.

 
Rihanna's Little Dior Darling Makes Her Campaign Debut

Rihanna's Little Dior Darling Makes Her Campaign Debut